The 5 Best Pillow Alternatives to MyPillow

Last Updated September 2021

Editor’s Pick (1st Choice)

Coop Home Goods’ Eden pillow is the obvious choice for me. I lay my head on this pillow every night. It has literally changed my life!

Reader’s Choice (2nd Best Choice)

The Weekender Memory foam pillow is one of the best selling pillows on Amazon. With 21,000+ reviews, it is hard to go wrong with this one.

Runner Up (3rd Best Choice)

The DreamyBlue shredded memory foam pillow is a great choice for a great price. A great budget pick if you’re looking for an adjustable pillow

How to Choose the Best Pillow Alternative to “MyPillow”

It is not always easy to get a good night’s sleep. Bad rest environments, frequent stress, and busy schedules can all be causes for sleep issues.

Also, it is more common than you would imagine. According to the American Sleep Association, 50-70 million people have a sleep disorder in the US alone.

That’s why it may be time for you to purchase a new pillow if your sleepless nights are affecting your health.

Nowadays, pillows offer a lot of amazing features:

One of the most popular pillows today is MyPillow. The MyPillow pillow was made to provide sleepers of all forms of pressure relief and comfort by allowing its users to adjust the amount of memory foam fill for a fully customizable pillow.

Alternatives to MyPillow - Pillow fight graphic

What’s MyPillow made of?

One the biggest benefits of the MyPillow is its patented 100% open cell polyurethane foam. This adjustable foam is what provides the customizable comfort they are known for.

However, in our research we found some consumers concerned about the safety of the PBDE levels. So, we decided to look at some some the best MyPillow alternatives.

Luckily, we’ve found several pillows with CertiPUR-US and GreenGuard Gold certification (more on that later).

We’re including several pillows like MyPillow with both adjustable shredded memory foam and single slabs of memory foam.

What Are We Looking for in an Alternative?

Our goal in this review was to find pillows with similar levels of comfort and quality. We’ll look for:

  • Comfort Levels
  • Softness
  • Quality of Sleep
  • Adjustability
  • Quality of Materials
  • User Ratings

We are here to help you. Here are our 5 best pillow alternatives to MyPillow. You just may find a pillow that is even better than MyPillow!

The 5 Best Pillows Comparable to MyPillow

Coop Home Goods Eden Pillow (Editor’s Choice)

The Coop Home Goods Eden Pillow is our first pick and the pillow we actually use at home.

The fully adjustable gel-infused memory foam and microfiber fill provides a cooling effect and allows you to customize the pillow to your exact needs for maximum comfort. This pillow eliminated my nagging neck pain!

They’ve used only the best materials – from the proprietary Lulltra fabric and a woven gusset to allow the fill to distribute evenly.

Coop Home Goods best sleep guarantee gives you 100 nights to try the pillow out. If you do not love it, you get a no questions asked 100% refund just for trying it out.

Quick Facts

The Coop Home Goods Eden pillow is certified by CertiPUR-US and GREENGUARD Gold to ensure safety: no PBDE’s, heavy metals, formaldehyde, and low VOC’s, and is completely hypoallergenic. These pillows are made in the USA, specifically in California where PBDE’s are banned.

Pros

  • 100% Adjustable Fill – Great Balance Between Comfort & Support
  • Hypoallergenic & Certified for low chemical emission

  • Gel-Infused filling provides a cooling effect – perfect for hot sleepers
  • Includes an extra bag of fill.
  • 100 Day (Night) Guarantee

Cons

  • Priciest Option

  • Slight chemical smell first few nights.
  • Can take some adjustments to get the perfect fill level for you.
  • It is reported that the filling can go flat over time.

Weekender Memory Foam Pillow (Reader’s Choice)

The Weekender Memory Foam Pillow boasts nearly 22,000 4.4 star (average) ratings as of this writing and is one of the best selling pillows on Amazon

Infused with temperature regulating gel and ventilated for air circulation, the Weekender’s memory foam is a good choice for hot sleepers.

While the Weekender is not adjustable like a shredded foam pillow, don’t let that deter you. Users report a wonderful sleep experience with unmatched comfort and support.

If you are looking for a non-adjustable pillow, it is hard to go wrong with this one.

Quick Facts

The sheer volume of reviews (22,000) and counting is astounding and speaks volumes about the quality and comfort factor. Clear reader’s choice winner!

The Weekender pillow is certified by CertiPUR-US to ensure safety: no PBDE’s, heavy metals, formaldehyde, and low VOC’s.

Pros

  • Provides a great balance in softness and firmness
  • Hypoallergenic & Certified for low chemical emission

  • Gel-Infused and ventilated to keep cool
  • $$$ Cost Effective!

Cons

  • Not adjustable
  • Slight chemical smell first few nights.
  • Pillow cover can get rough over time.
  • Not hypoallergenic.

DreamyBlue Shredded Memory Foam Pillow (Runner Up)

The DreamyBlue Shredded Memory Foam Pillow is one of the highest rated pillows with a whopping 4.7 average rating earning it a solid 3rd place.

The DreamyBlue Pillow utilizes their own proprietary blend of shredded memory foam, allowing you to customize your pillow to your preferred sleeping position and head height.

With a soft and breathable hypoallergenic pillow case, the DreamyBlue Pillow provides comfort for a great night of sleep.

The DreamyBlue Pillow is very similar to the Coop Home Goods Pillow without the premium price.

Quick Facts

This pillow has the highest rating of all the pillows we’ve reviewed. and is quite reasonably priced. A good buy.

The DreamyBlue Pillow is certified by CertiPUR-US to ensure safety: no PBDE’s, heavy metals, formaldehyde, and low VOC’s.

Pros

  • Highest Rated Pillow!
  • 100% Fully Adjustable for the perfect softness and firmness combination
  • Certified for low chemical emission
  • Lifetime Replacement Guarantee
  • Top-Notch customer service

Cons

  • Strong chemical smell
  • Can get warm. Not great for hot sleepers.
  • Construction of inner-pillow case not constructed well.
  • Possible knock-offs

SnugglePedic Bamboo – Shredded Memory Foam Pillow

The Snuggle-Pedic Original USA Made Ultra-Luxury Bamboo Shredded Memory Foam Pillow is a great pick because it has all the qualities that you need at a price that won’t let you cash in all your savings! See our full review.

Memory foam pillows are intended to conform to the sleeper.. The Snuggle-Pedic Bamboo Shredded Memory Foam Pillow contains shredded foam filling. Because of this, it is customizable and thus perfect for any form of sleeper.

One of the best features of the Snuggle-Pedic pillow is that it provides excellent orthopedic support. Also, the special blend of fluffiness and resilience will adjust to every position you sleep in. This makes it the ideal head-rest for the stomach, back, and side sleepers.

Quick Facts

Snuggle-Pedic pillows were designed by a chiropractor for perfect support and are made in the USA.

It is also GreenGuard Gold certified so you can rest easy!

Pros

  • Designed by a Chiropractor
  • 100% Adjustable like “MyPillow”
  • GreenGuard Gold Certification & Allergy Free
  • 120-Night Sleep Guarantee + 20-Year Warranty!

  • Fantastic Customer Service

Cons

  • Slight off-gassing smell.

  • Some customers were sent pillows without a zipper for customization.
  • Flattens quickly
  • Possible foam quality issues with some customers reporting that it is too soft and some saying it is too firm.

Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-Cloud Memory Foam Pillow

Every knows the Tempur-Pedic brand and is one of the reasons we chose to review the TEMPUR-Cloud memory foam pillow.

Tempur-Pedic’s proprietary “Tempur” memory foam material provides a soft but supportive pillow – ideal for back and side sleepers.

This Tempur-cloud pillow is the soft version and earns great points for softness. It seems that the height of the pillow can be a little uncomfortable for stomach sleepers.

It is a great pillow, but if you’d rather an non-adjustable pillow, the Weekender may be a better alternative at a better price.

Quick Facts

Tempur material was actually developed by NASA as a means to improve seat cushioning. A Swedish scientist continued this work for sleeping and founded Tempur-Pedic. They are the originals!

Note – there has been reports of knock-offs being sold on Amazon. Be careful to buy direct from Tempur-Pedic if buying on Amazon or buy from your nearest retail store until these issues are ironed out just to be safe.

Pros

  • Great balance between support and softness.

  • The “original” memory foam.
  • Tempur-Pedic is one of the top memory foam brands. High quality.
  • Certi-PUR-US Certified – no harmful chemicals and low VOC’s.

  • 5-Year Warranty

Cons

  • Not great for stomach sleepers.
  • Not adjustable.
  • Does not offer a sleep trial on pillows. Need to be certain on your desired level of softness.
  • A bit warmer than other pillows reviewed.
FREE 12 WEEK PROGRAM!
I agree to have my personal information transfered to AWeber ( more information )
If you would want to get our FREE 12-week email series of pain relieving tips, techniques, studies, and products. Plus, 21 habits to destress and relax, sign up here!
Spam is the worst. Your email address will not be sold or shared with anyone else.

Is Choosing the Right Pillow Important?

An excellent sleeping posture is a key to sleeping comfortably every night. It is also vital to waking without stiffness and pain. For those who don’t know, aside from your mattress, your pillow also helps to support a healthy sleep posture. So, what does a healthy sleep posture look like?

Well, in order to achieve a healthy sleep posture, your body needs to be aligned. From the hips and knees, through the spine to the shoulders and chest, neck, and head.

It will put your body and spine out of alignment if your shoulders and necks do not get enough support, or are positioned at an angle that causes crunching, craning, or twisting.

This will result in discomfort and strain in your back, shoulders, and neck. Aside from that, it can also lead to sleepless nights.

Just like your mattress, support, and comfort are both crucial in choosing the correct pillow. The ideal pillow for you is one that feels comfortable to rest on.

Aside from that, it should match your mattress when it comes to supporting your shoulders, neck, and head.

Choosing a pillow greatly depends on your preferences. There is actually no material, shape, or size that fits all when it comes to choosing the right pillow. The ideal way to look for the pillow that’s best for you is to figure out your own needs.

Another thing to consider is your mattress. You might be better off with a softer pillow if you utilize a firm mattress. Of course, you will be better off with a firmer pillow if you use a soft mattress.

How to Choose the Best Pillow for You?

The 5 pillows we have mentioned above are the best alternatives to MyPillow. However, how do you choose the best one for you? There is one huge thing you have to consider. What is your go-to sleeping position?

Obviously, there aren’t any rules that designate one pillow to every position. Every person sleeps. We all sleep differently.

Regardless of your favored position, the most crucial task of the pillow is to support healthy posture by keeping your spine, neck, and head in neutral alignment.

For those who don’t know, you will find the phrase “Neutral Spine Alignment” in almost every feature of pillows.

Basically, Neutral Spine Alignment means that the natural C-curve of the spine is being supported instead of being craned into an unsafe position.

All you have to do is to check if your chin is in line with your sternum and your ears are in line with your shoulders if you want to know if your spine is in neutral alignment.

Here are a couple of crucial factors to think about when looking for the pillow that is ideal for your favored sleep position.

Stomach Sleeping

Stomach sleepers have to stick to a fast and hard rule to keep neutral spine alignment, unlike back sleepers.

Stomach Sleeping Position Correct Spinal Alignment

A soft pillow with a low loft is going to support your spine’s natural curve if you are a stomach sleeper.

This will also help avoid your neck/head from being craned upwards. Looking for a stomach sleeper pillow can be a bit difficult since it can be extremely simple to strain your neck when you sleep on your stomach.

Back Sleeping

Back sleepers should stick to a happy medium build when it comes to feel and firmness.

Basically, this means that the firmness and loft need to have a medium rating. This will help encourage a healthy posture.

Back Sleeping Position Incorrect Spinal Alignment

Incorrect Positioning

Correct Positioning

However, back sleepers have a bit more room to experiment with firmness and loft. They also have to consider neutral spine alignment.

For those who don’t know, most back sleepers alternate between various positions. Because of this, you will need a pillow for combination sleepers.

Side Sleeping

Usually, side sleepers are most compatible with pillows that provide a lofty profile and a firmer feel.

Side Sleeping Poistion - Neutral Spine

A pillow with 4” or higher loft will provide comfort while holding your head in alignment with the spine. It also relieves pressure at the hips and shoulders.

On the other hand, a firmer level of support will avoid your head from slowly sinking down while you sleep.

Conclusion

After reviewing these five pillows, we don’t feel that there was a bad choice in the bunch.

Choosing a pillow is a very personal decision. This makes the sleep guarantee and easy returns important. You may want to try them out before you commit to just one.

All five of these pillows are similar to MyPillow. Which one did you choose? Tell us in the comments!

Editor’s Choice

MisterBack’s #1 Recommendation

An easy choice. All pillows in the review were great, but the Coop Home Goods Eden PIllow is the one I sleep with, and I love it. In fact, I’ve written my name on it to ensure my wife doesn’t steal my pillow!

I was able to adjust it perfectly for side and back sleeping. It is a little too firm for stomach sleeping, so that may be something to consider if you are a primary stomach sleeper.

FREE 12 WEEK PROGRAM!
I agree to have my personal information transfered to AWeber ( more information )
If you would want to get our FREE 12-week email series of pain relieving tips, techniques, studies, and products. Plus, 21 habits to destress and relax, sign up here!
Spam is the worst. Your email address will not be sold or shared with anyone else.